Michigan sides with El-Sayed over eligibility question
August 2018 update: Gretchen Whitmer wins Democratic primary for Michigan governor
Michigan elections officials on Wednesday tossed out nearly a dozen challenges to Dr. Abdul El-Sayed’s eligibility to run for governor, arguing the Democrat has been a registered Michigan voter for 15 straight years.
Even so, speculation about El-Sayed’s eligibility, first raised in January in Bridge, may not be yet over. A lawsuit that El-Sayed brought asking for a declaratory judgment of his eligibility as a candidate is pending in the Michigan Court of Claims.
Shri Thanedar, an Ann Arbor businessman who is competing against the former Detroit health director in the August Democratic primary, filed a challenge, as did 10 others, out of concern that El-Sayed’s stint living and working in New York made him ineligible to run for governor this year.
Related: It’s Thanedar vs. El-Sayed, as Michigan gov hopefuls square off over eligibility
Related: Abdul El-Sayed’s stint in NYC may derail bid for Michigan governor
The Michigan Bureau of Elections rejected all challenges on the grounds that the request “does not cite any legal authority to support your contentions; nor does it provide any documentary evidence that contradicts the information submitted to the Department by Dr. El-Sayed in his Affidavit of Identity, or the information contained in the (Qualified Voter File).”
May 2018: Abdul El-Sayed clears eligibility hurdle in bid for Michigan governor
El-Sayed's campaign issued a statement on Wednesday saying the ruling affirmed his long-held stance that he is "100 percent" eligible to be on the ballot.
"While we anticipate that this definitive statement of fact by the Bureau of Elections won’t stop political opponents from persisting in their baseless smear campaign, Abdul’s supporters and everyday voters can be fully confident in their support of Abdul," El-Sayed campaign spokesman Adam Joseph wrote in a statement.
Thanedar's campaign released a statement Thursday saying “we are thankful the Secretary of State's office reviewed this matter and look forward to an open and vigorous debate on how we can move our state forward and help working families rise up."
The elections bureau said in letters to the challengers that staff reviewed El-Sayed’s voter registration record, which is standard practice for all candidates for state office. El-Sayed has been a registered Michigan voter since 2003, according to the state.
The Michigan constitution requires that candidates for governor be a “registered elector in this state” for four years before the general election in which they’re running. El-Sayed was still a registered voter in New York as recently as 2015 and had a driver license in that state while he worked at Columbia University in New York City.
He updated his voting address in Michigan in 2016, Michigan records show.
State records have shown that El-Sayed’s registration was on a “cancellation countdown” after he changed his driver license out of state. But Michigan elections officials said that his voter registration could not be canceled until two federal general elections went by without him casting a ballot in Michigan, or unless the state received written notice that he changed his address to vote.
Related: Campaign eligibility is tricky, but has tripped up Michigan candidates
Opinion: Don’t let Islamophobia spoil Abdul El-Sayed’s campaign for governor
Related: Abdul El-Sayed says how he would help Michigan cities as governor
Secretary of State Ruth Johnson has asked the Court of Claims to dismiss El-Sayed’s lawsuit on the grounds that it’s a premature request.
In a brief filed Wednesday, attorneys for the state noted that El-Sayed’s eligibility remains speculative — though to a lesser degree — because state canvassers have not yet certified that he submitted enough signatures from registered state voters to qualify for the ballot.
State elections spokesman Fred Woodhams said via email Wednesday that the department has not changed its position on the case. The new brief notes the state’s determination that El-Sayed’s Michigan voter registration was never canceled.
The Bureau of Elections is still reviewing the validity of signatures filed by candidates for governor and other offices to make the Aug. 7 primary ballot, Woodhams said. The Board of State Canvassers will need to meet in order to certify the candidates who will appear on the ballot, which could happen this month.
On Wednesday, though, El-Sayed took to Facebook to celebrate the eligibility ruling with an ice cream sundae.
See what new members are saying about why they donated to Bridge Michigan:
- “In order for this information to be accurate and unbiased it must be underwritten by its readers, not by special interests.” - Larry S.
- “Not many other media sources report on the topics Bridge does.” - Susan B.
- “Your journalism is outstanding and rare these days.” - Mark S.
If you want to ensure the future of nonpartisan, nonprofit Michigan journalism, please become a member today. You, too, will be asked why you donated and maybe we'll feature your quote next time!